As the WWE universe gears up for SummerSlam 2025’s two-night spectacle, speculation swirls around a potential shock return that could reshape the event’s narrative. Among the marquee matchups, all eyes are on Jade Cargill’s challenge for the WWE Women’s Championship against titleholder Tiffany Stratton during the first night of “The Biggest Party of the Summer.” While the bout promises high stakes, rumors suggest an even bigger story may unfold involving three-time world champion Bianca Belair, whose absence since WrestleMania 41 could end with a dramatic, character-altering twist.
Sources close to WWE creative teams have floated the possibility of Belair making a surprise comeback during the Cargill-Stratton clash, potentially interfering to cost Cargill the match and marking her first turn as a villainous “heel” character. Belair, often referred to by her “EST of WWE” moniker, has been sidelined since April after sustaining multiple fractures in her right ring finger during a WrestleMania 41 match. While WWE has not officially confirmed these plans, industry analysts note that SummerSlam’s reputation for pivotal moments makes it an ideal stage for such a storyline shift.
The injury update comes directly from Belair herself, who recently spoke to Chris Van Vliet on his INSIGHT podcast. Detailing the severity of her WrestleMania mishap, she revealed: “I broke it in two or three different spots—up in the middle and down in the joint. It’s healed, but it won’t fully straighten. Now I have to wear my ring on the other hand.” Despite the lingering physical effects, Belair’s medical clearance reportedly aligns with SummerSlam’s timeline, fueling speculation about her involvement.
Cargill, who earned her title opportunity by winning June’s Queen of the Ring tournament, represents a formidable challenge for Stratton, the rising star who claimed the championship earlier this year. A controversial finish involving Belair could set up a fresh rivalry while reigniting debates about her unfinished business with Cargill; the two last clashed in a tag team match at WrestleMania.
WWE’s creative strategies often use major events to reintroduce sidelined athletes, capitalizing on renewed fan interest. Belair’s potential heel turn—a significant departure from her longstanding fan-favorite persona—would mark a career pivot for the 34-year-old star, whose athleticism and charisma have anchored women’s division storylines since her 2020 main roster debut.
As SummerSlam approaches, neither WWE nor Belair has confirmed the rumored angle, emphasizing that current discussions remain speculative. However, with the event’s history of delivering unexpected twists, the possibility of Belair’s return underscores the high-stakes nature of WWE’s flagship summer showcase.
